On October 9, 2026, the Fourth Department issued a decision in Wilmington Trust, N.A. v. Stradtman Park, LLC, 2026 NY Slip Op. 05883, holding that was not error to cut a fee award based on the requested fees being unreasonably high, explaining:
We reject plaintiff’s further contention that the court abused its discretion in determining the amount of the attorneys’ fees awarded. Defendant did not dispute that plaintiff and LNR were entitled to attorneys’ fees, but it contested the reasonableness of the requested fees, relying on expert testimony regarding reasonable fees for commercial mortgage foreclosure actions in Western New York. Defendant’s expert opined that a customary, reasonable fee for an experienced attorney in commercial foreclosure proceedings in Western New York would range from $350 to $450 an hour. Plaintiff’s sole witness testified that LNR was paying between $650-800 an hour for the services of law firm partners and between $350-575 an hour for associates. None of the attorney invoices submitted by plaintiff delineated the rate for each charge. Plaintiff requested approximately $588,000 in attorneys’ fees, but the court awarded only $250,000, finding that the rates requested by plaintiff were unreasonable and that numerous charges were duplicative and exaggerated. Indeed, the court noted that plaintiff had come “perilously close” to having the entire judgment vacated due to its exorbitant request for attorneys’ fees.
An award of attorneys’ fees, even if permitted by contract, may only be enforced to the extent that the amount is reasonable and warranted for the services actually rendered. Such a determination involves a review of the number of hours spent on the case, the hourly rate that was being charged, and the customary fees charged for services by lawyers in the community with like experience and reputation. We conclude that the court’s determination to award $250,000 was not an abuse of discretion and should not be disturbed.
(Internal quotations and citations omitted).
